To ask other readers questions about Obligate Carnivore , please sign up. Lists with This Book. Community Reviews. Showing Rating details. More filters. Sort order.
Satya Jan/Feb The Case for Vegan Cats by Jed Gillen
Sep 10, Craig? I have a vegan dog. The author makes solid argument after solid argument in defense of feeding your furry loved ones dogs AND cats a vegan diet.
View 1 comment. I really did go into this book a skeptic. I've always justified feeding meet to cats as necessary, while I knew that it was possible for a dog to live on a vegan diet. But I'm convinced enough to at least give it a try.
Are you sure?
I'm just curious weather my cats would actually EAT a vegan cat food. I'll buy it, and find out. At this moment, I reserve the moral sanction to continue to feed them meat based cat food, only so long as they refuse to eat the vegitarian stuff.
- Shop by category?
- Pop Finance: Investment Clubs and the New Investor Populism;
- NO, You Can't Feed Your Cat a Vegan Diet | hitovaru.tk.
I'm still trying to get them used to the wet stuff. I also add a little extra water to it, the vegan stuff is a little too dry. Mar 09, Angie rated it did not like it Shelves: read-in There are basically no sources listed in this book to back up the author's claims. He uses purely anecdotal "evidence" and his own experiences to back up everything that he says.
On his "Resource" page, the only thing listed is his own website because, and I quote directly, "It is the only place you will ever need to go, which is why this section is labeled 'Resource' instead of 'Resources'". Pardon me while I remain incredibly skeptical.
Show me some real peer-reviewed science to back up your c There are basically no sources listed in this book to back up the author's claims. Show me some real peer-reviewed science to back up your claims, include resources other than only the word of one individual to go by, and maybe I can consider your thoughts with a little more credibility. Don't waste your time. Jan 06, John Stockman rated it liked it. I am not much for propaganda, but it is good info if you are wondering if you can safely raise your companion animals a vegan diet, thereby cutting your last tie to the meat and dairy industry.
And in case you are wondering, yes you can Oct 05, Ray user rated it it was amazing Recommends it for: pet owners. Do you know what's really in your pet's food? Perhaps you should. Apr 15, Fallopia rated it really liked it Recommends it for: anyone who loves to laugh, anyone who has a cat or dog at home to feed.
Shelves: nonfiction , cats-n-dogs. So far, the definitive book on vegan cats Well, both my cat who was 20 at the end of and my dog who passed away at 14 in were "grandfathered" as carnivores when I became a vegetarian in , mainly because I didn't want to rock the proverbial boat. My roommate is a staunch omnivore, who believes cats and dogs need to eat meat to be healthy, and I had never even questioned this thinking myself until I stopped eating meat.
But the more I read, the more I was determined to feed my new So far, the definitive book on vegan cats Well, both my cat who was 20 at the end of and my dog who passed away at 14 in were "grandfathered" as carnivores when I became a vegetarian in , mainly because I didn't want to rock the proverbial boat.
But the more I read, the more I was determined to feed my new kitten now six months old a vegan diet. Naturally, there was friction at home over this, and lots of yelling. I had been responsible for bringing the kitten home in the first place, and I had paid the adoption fee; after I backed down, offered to feed the cat a raw-meat diet, and give away the remaining vegan kibble we have here, Richard relented, saying we might as well try the kitten on the vegan food, and see how he does.
Jed Gillen's single motivation in feeding his pets vegan diets as well as for his own veganism is ethical: to not be responsible for any animal having to suffer just to feed him. He considers the health and environmental benefits of not having to kill animals for food just fringe benefits to his main cause, asserting that, "I have said that I would remain vegan myself even if I were to find out that it were not the absolute best choice from the standpoint of my personal health. Armed with a philosophy degree, Mr.cellanet.ca/magia-negra-magia-blanca.php
Would you feed your cat a vegan diet?
Gillen crafts a compelling argument for "veganizing" one's cat or dog. And he makes indisputable arguments, such as that the "prey drive" should never be considered a "need" to eat meat. I'm really happy that this book exists, and I'm going to order several more copies for people of the "your dog needs meat to live" school of thought—i.
The most unfortunate thing I see, though, is that a lot of omnivores flat-out refuse to read Obligate Carnivore ; this is sad, because it's an eminently readable and often funny book. And for me, the motivation to become vegan is still three-pronged; when I consider that animals are dying of heart disease and cancer in numbers that parallel the human population, I'm willing to try another way.
If you can maintain a dog or cat as well on a vegan diet for as long a life as on meat, it seems reasonable to try. And if there are enviromental benefits as well, that just makes it more of a compelling argument for me. First - this book is pages, not as is listed here on Goodreads. Second - skip the first pages.
Obligate Carnivore : Cats, Dogs & What It Really Means to Be Vegan, 2nd Edition
They are poorly organized, badly written, disjointed and just not all that interesting or helpful. They rant and ramble - like a collection of badly written blog and twitter updates thrown together. Starting at page - the section about Cat Urine - and ending with the next chapter about making the transition, the author finally provides some interesting and helpful descriptions of first First - this book is pages, not as is listed here on Goodreads.
Starting at page - the section about Cat Urine - and ending with the next chapter about making the transition, the author finally provides some interesting and helpful descriptions of first hand experience. The rest of the book is just a bunch of moralizing. Honestly - I don't feed my cats crappy cat food.
Click here. Reviews 0 Add Review You need to be logged in to add a review. Login here Create Account. No 4 Star Reviews yet. No 3 Star Reviews yet. No 2 Star Reviews yet. No 1 Star Reviews yet. No reviews yet. Combining obligate with carnivore is pretty clear. Cats must eat meat, it is a biological necessity. Because eating a meat-only diet provides some vitamins and fatty acids in their pre-formed state, cats and many other obligate carnivores have lost the ability to make these amino acids and vitamins in their own bodies the way herbivores or omnivores do.
They have little ability to form niacin from tryptophan. They have a high requirement for taurine, which is found almost exclusively in animal flesh. Arginine, also found in animal flesh, is so critical to the cat that a meal without it can lead to death. Fortunately, all meat sources have plenty.
Simply put, cats must eat meat to live.
- What Exactly is an 'Obligate Carnivore?'.
- Let Me Heal: The Opportunity to Preserve Excellence in American Medicine!
- Can't vegans and vegetarians just get along? - Los Angeles Times?
- Obligate Carnivore?
- Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Man-Machine-Environment System Engineering?
- The Philosophy of Hilary Putnam.
- Additional Reading.
The vocal support of a vegan diet for cats comes strictly from the vegan community itself. He states the following:. The animals we feed to our cats and dogs have been genetically manipulated, pumped full of hormones, confined, beaten, and murdered without ever having had a chance at a normal life.